Patricia
Blights
New Member
Can you stop dropping that Sweetie
Posts - 176
Likes - 82
Joined - November 2019
|
Post by Patricia on May 3, 2020 8:18:57 GMT -5
It's the kind of dumb shit the mods might do just to fuck with everyone. Or we could just be wrong. But idk, if there's a better idea someone can change it I guess. But I think this is as good as any other option we have.
|
|
Oaki
Blights
New Member
Buy my motorcycles
Posts - 223
Likes - 96
Joined - November 2019
|
Post by Oaki on May 3, 2020 8:22:37 GMT -5
Given that Hunnie and Mipha had the same archetypes though, I think you're right on the "template being reused" thing. Because they are in the same spot on the table.
|
|
Master Kohga
Blights
New Member
Posts - 159
Likes - 105
Joined - November 2019
|
Post by Master Kohga on May 3, 2020 11:16:40 GMT -5
Here is what Horse sent me. Of course, this could be misdirection.
I believe that SOMEBODY has Bow. I just think one tribe copied a real word from the other.
I don't really understand where we got City from, but it seems really like it doesn't match the general theme of all the other words. I was thinking it was possible Sword and Bow were the real words while Axe was fake, on the grounds that Sword and Bow are both connected with the Zelda games in general (which most of the words obviously are - even wolf, for that matter).
If we wish to confirm how likely template reusage is, would it help in any way to clearly state what order our own words were in?
I don't know if we can assume that, for instance, every tribe has one food item and one weapon. That might be the pattern, but I don't think we can be certain.
|
|
Master Kohga
Blights
New Member
Posts - 159
Likes - 105
Joined - November 2019
|
Post by Master Kohga on May 3, 2020 11:18:17 GMT -5
I also suspect that Hunnie simply invented Axe because she identified Sword as our word and it's similar.
|
|
Master Kohga
Blights
New Member
Posts - 159
Likes - 105
Joined - November 2019
|
Post by Master Kohga on May 3, 2020 12:05:20 GMT -5
If we have no other ideas, we could take a shot at lava or a similar word such as flame. Lava does at least have something to do with Zelda, though I think it's more likely that person was faking us out.
|
|
Prince Sidon
Blights
New Member
Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson of Hyrule
Posts - 261
Likes - 121
Joined - November 2019
|
Post by Prince Sidon on May 3, 2020 13:56:15 GMT -5
city isn't really sitting right with me, idk. but the whole "matching 1:1 for a template" thing is what i was doing earlier then i just deleted my post bc i thought it would be insane to do that, but if yall are on board, im on board with the template axe is a big assumption from us yeah, and i cant help but point out that revali mentioned bow in his songs. he also mentioned mushrooms thoughh. so idk how useful any of it is. this feels like a crapshoot either way, but are we assuming animals: horse/bird/wolf food: apple/mushroom/meat weapon: bomb/??axe??/sword (i really think axe could be wrong if weve seen bow mentioned so many times and it fits more with zelda, but it being mentioned to us AFTER we already said we werent on their tribe might make it a throwaway) location: ??city??/shrine/forest so what's the spirit equivalent then? i guess fairy and  or is desert the location and shrine is the spirit equivalent? |
|
Master Kohga
Blights
New Member
Posts - 159
Likes - 105
Joined - November 2019
|
Post by Master Kohga on May 3, 2020 14:54:49 GMT -5
i suppose for the ones we have no idea about it seems fine to guess there might be symmetry
would rather put bow down in some places than axe. i feel like the location thing might not be a thing though. because many of the other words feel forest related (mushroom, apple, wolf), my feeling is that the whole thing is forest related
|
|
Ancient Oven
Blights
New Member
*beep*
Posts - 162
Likes - 118
Joined - November 2019
|
Post by Ancient Oven on May 3, 2020 15:18:07 GMT -5
My message from DesignateRoyalHorse.
"Hello, we have yet to meet each other! How was Goron City? Gerudo City required me to put some silly bows in my mane and ruin my entire hairdo, which was horrifying, but I suppose I'll live, my heart is just broken.
I also hope the self-isolation hasn't been too harsh on you, I just finished making some delicious cream of mushroom soup with freshly baked bread. This quarantine has certainly been a great help in advancing my cooking skills."
Heart, Bow, Mushroom seem like the common traits. I agree with there being no axes involved in Zelda.
|
|
Ancient Oven
Blights
New Member
*beep*
Posts - 162
Likes - 118
Joined - November 2019
|
Post by Ancient Oven on May 3, 2020 15:22:57 GMT -5
Until Robbie posted it seems like that tribe didn't know who their fifth member was.
|
|
Prince Sidon
Blights
New Member
Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson of Hyrule
Posts - 261
Likes - 121
Joined - November 2019
|
Post by Prince Sidon on May 3, 2020 15:41:36 GMT -5
yep i like bow over axe
|
|
Master Kohga
Blights
New Member
Posts - 159
Likes - 105
Joined - November 2019
|
Post by Master Kohga on May 3, 2020 16:54:17 GMT -5
It occurs to me that apple mushroom and neat are all the main staples you cook with in breath of the wild specifically. Want to think about words related to that. Heart is such a weird choice since it was one of the tribe names, but hey maybe.
|
|
Master Kohga
Blights
New Member
Posts - 159
Likes - 105
Joined - November 2019
|
Post by Master Kohga on May 3, 2020 17:02:36 GMT -5
urbosa used the word "slate" in her message to me (i.e. sheikah slate) but it was so smooth i didn't think anything of it until now.
tower? that would fit with shrine if that's a real thing.
hunnie's list also contains apple, which suggests all the more than we should probably consider ignoring her.
revali's first song could relate to bird. are we pretty sure that's on the other tribe?
revali also has a song named oasis, which seems obviously related to desert, another word we currently have assigned to the other tribe for i dont remember what reason.
we currently have royal white horse as telling the truth about some of their words and not others, which seems sort of unlikely to me.
|
|
Prince Sidon
Blights
New Member
Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson of Hyrule
Posts - 261
Likes - 121
Joined - November 2019
|
Post by Prince Sidon on May 3, 2020 18:06:50 GMT -5
right, i think horse wouldve told the truth.
im sorry but i have to go eat dinner, but i co-sign what kohga said above. i really think revali has bird/wing/something based on his songs. and one of his other songs is clever enough to include the word bow in it, but it's in the "take a bow" context instead of the "bow and arrow" context, and that's the subtle thing i thought he would try to do.
but then bomb/bow together makes no sense.
i dont feel great about this challenge but i just dont have the information needed.
|
|
Oaki
Blights
New Member
Buy my motorcycles
Posts - 223
Likes - 96
Joined - November 2019
|
Post by Oaki on May 3, 2020 18:43:17 GMT -5
To clarify:
Are we replacing Desert with Shrine?
Since we had Shrine on the not-Revali Tribe (their names aren't in the spreadsheet so I dunno who's who), do we want to strike desert and put in heart instead?
Axe can be replaced with Bow
|
|
Patricia
Blights
New Member
Can you stop dropping that Sweetie
Posts - 176
Likes - 82
Joined - November 2019
|
Post by Patricia on May 3, 2020 18:47:34 GMT -5
I was assuming heart was a reference to the tribe name not a passcode. That seems hella weird to me, but idk. Where does Lava come in, or is that a herring?
|
|
or is desert the location and shrine is the spirit equivalent?
